I Can’t Afford a $25,000 a Year Pay Cut – Now What?

I’m writing this as I prepare to meet my husband for lunch, where I’m going to have to tell him the ugly truth – the job I’ve been interviewing for, that I told him I wanted to pursue, I can’t afford.

We both knew it involved a pay cut, at least initially. I currently make over $80K a year, and this job is base+ commission; the base being tossed around is $60K. The catch? It will take me at least 6 months to earn commissions strong enough to get back to my current salary (after that, the potential exists to earn significantly more than I do now). The net result, the best I can estimate, is that we would lose between $600 – $750 per month of my take home pay.

I really thought we could handle the cut for a few months. I mean, right now, over $400 a month of my cheques go directly to my pension plan, plus I have other required deductions too. I thought we could handle it – until I ran the numbers last night. The truth is, for us to afford for me to take this job means we cut debt payment almost entirely for 6+ months – minimum payments only. The rest of our budget would be squeezed so tight there would be no room for a single mistake.

I can’t ask my husband to put up with that. We have a couple of options – we are still trying to rent out a room in our house (surprisingly more difficult than I thought it would be). If we were able to do that, we would replace  $400 of my missing income. The risk? If the renter doesn’t work out, we’re back to being super tight. I could also look for a part time job to off set the income loss until my commissions kick in. Unlike my current job, which has strange, unpredictable hours, this job is a regular M-F, 9-5 gig. I’d be tired, and I’d have to sacrifice some training time, but triathlon season is almost over anyway. I could also put more effort into trying to get my side hustles going, making money with menu plans, through blogging, etc.

I’m really torn – not because this was my dream job, although I do think I’d enjoy it and could be quite good at it. I really, really need to get out of my current job, and I’ll write a full post on that soon. I also am tempted by the commission numbers being thrown at me – I could earn more than double what I’m making right now. I won’t say “easily” because it’s commission, and I suspect I’d work pretty hard for it. But the earning potential is definitely there. Plus the organization has offices worldwide, so the possibility of moving one day is there too. It’s so frustrating that our financial situation has put me here! The final kicker – this job is something so outside my comfort zone, I was actually looking forward to the challenge of becoming stronger at doing things I’ve always thought I was no good at. I wanted to prove to myself that I could do these things!

 


Comments

I Can’t Afford a $25,000 a Year Pay Cut – Now What? — 14 Comments

  1. That is frustrating! If you can fulfill the gap with the side gigs/part time job/renter if only for a little bit, with all the pros you listed, I’d say try for it.Keep us filled in–I’m sending good thoughts your way that it will work out for you!

    • Well, I’m going to see if I can negotiate a higher base, maybe with a lower commission percentage. If I can, then I can seriously look at it. But $2000 a month cut is just more than we can handle. :(

    • I keep telling myself, whatever happens will be for the best – even if “the best” is simply the kick in the pants I needed to really get serious about our debt and launching some side hustles!

  2. I think that is incredibly frustrating, especially since the potential of the amount of money you COULD make is so enticing, practically dancing in front of you and begging you to “choose me choose me!” but at the same time your rationale is telling you to not take it. I think that your reasons for wanting the job are good reasons, but I would also stay at the current job if you absolutely need the salary security. I can’t wait to read about why you want to leave your current job though!

    • The potential is really tempting, and I’m trying not to let that lure suck me in to making a mistake. The leaving my current job post will be coming next week. I’m trying to be careful – no one I work with knows about this blog, but I don’t want to risk my job by venting too much either!

    • If I had the extra cushion, I’d take the job. Am I taking it for the right reasons? Well, that’s a good question!

  3. Wow really tough decision. I know it’s totally cliche, but go with your gut. Even if it’s the job with the pay cut, somehow I’m sure you will adjust and/or find new ways to make up that money.

    • I’m definitely working on finding a way to accept the job. First step, trying to negotiate a higher base. Second alternative, waiting 6 months (this may be an option), paying down debt, and then making the move.

  4. Wow, it sounds like quite a dilemma. I’m sorry things aren’t working out a little better for you.

    That would be quite an initial pay cut, but sometimes things like that can actually make us stronger in the end. I hope that whatever choice you make works out. :-) Good luck.

  5. That’s tough. The job sounds like a good challenge though, and if your current job isn’t working out… Hopefully you can find a way to make it work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>